Avatar
Reblogged tanoraqui
Avatar

Marvel Comics #1000: We’re Calling Him Ben

Avatar

I feel this is an important addition. He saves so many people on a regular basis that this just keeps happening. And he feels so much for his uncle that the answer is always the same.

Avatar
just-odradek

…. This hits different when you realise he’s canonically Jewish

Avatar

Can you please elaborate ? I’m curious as to what it means

Avatar
just-odradek

You can read a pretty good summary of it here, but as (most likely) Ashkenazi Jews, PP probably follows the minhag (custom) that says “that by naming a newborn child after a deceased loved one, the soul lives on through the child.” (Quoted from the site linked above.) And given how his Uncle Ben died, it just makes it all the more sadder tbh.

Avatar

another fine distinction is that the soul isn’t thought to be reincarnated, it’s that the memory of the loved one is kept alive and more good deeds in life can be inspired by (and thus partially attributed to) the dead. ‘may their memory be a blessing’–the memory of the deceased is honored, respected, and who they were is retold as inspiration to the next generation. 

ben’s memory is a blessing. that’s extremely jewish. spiderman is inspired not just by the shame of his death, but by the moral teachings he’d given peter in life. and his name given to these babies is another part of it: babies named in spiderman’s honor are also very honestly and truly named in his honor, and continue to be blessings to the world. 

it’s very joyous, i think. very sweet.  

Avatar

I swear to God I get happy tears every time I see these panels, and the commentary makes it even better

Avatar

Always reblog the jewish spiderman lore

227,891 notes
Replies are restricted for this post.
Avatar

Uncle Ben! You will always be in my heart

Avatar

I mean, this is super wholesome and lovely, but why in the world did they put so much detail into drawing his freaking arse?

Avatar

Why wouldn’t they

Avatar

Cause superhero’s, they are sexy beings so of course they get some cake!

Avatar

This is precious.

Avatar

This gave me emotional chills

Avatar

Wow that’s a lot of Bens! There’s got to be at least ten of ‘em!

Avatar

Funny, my first though was Peter used his brothers name and that was sweet.

Avatar

He has a brother?

Avatar

@pluurankeli No, but he has clone named Ben Riley so I think they got confused.

Avatar

@lakin520purple Riley being Aunt May’s maiden name.

Avatar

Ben is his uncle's name and his middle name - so both true and sentimental.

Avatar

@justlookatthosesausages the "you've been saved by spider man too "look

Avatar

This is so wholesome omg

Avatar

Hzhshxhshdhs 😣😣😣😣💚💚💚💚

Avatar

all these parents when Spidey reveals his identity: DICK MOVE

Avatar

Who else think the lady looks like like Amy Pond and even her husband kinda looks like Rory? ☺️

Avatar

Is nobody gonna mention that one of the kids named Ben clearly has two fathers? And that there might be a wlw couple behind the people in the park?

Avatar

There’s way too many kids named Ben all of a sudden lol

Avatar

Their classmates gonna be like “why tf are there 30 BENS ?!”

Avatar

That’s why he’s so popular

Avatar

@i-liek-chocolate-milk when I started to read whithout knowing what this what about, I tought the comic would be about a stalker or something like that 🤣

Avatar

Can you imagine how pissed the NY public school teachers must be when they start getting 15 Ben's in every class xD

Avatar

I’m Ashkenazi Jewish and I always forget that it’s a Jewish tradition and not just a thing

Avatar

so uncle ben's soul has a bunch of babies to choose from?

Avatar

Also, “Ben” means Son.

Avatar

I was like « haha he gave her a fake name » and then I realized- 😭

Avatar

Why am I crying? Tf

Avatar

not Benjamin??? just BEN???

Avatar

Ben could be short for many names, so I think they just chose the full name or just plain Ben if they wanted too.

Avatar

Aaaaaaahaghhhhhhhhhhhhh

Avatar

Oh Spider-Man’s one of us? Nice

Avatar

Is this seriously what people think pregnant women look like?

Avatar

Most comic artists don't know how to draw any kind of woman

Avatar

This is sooo sweet

Avatar

I mean, technically he is not lying.

Avatar

Also I noticed there’s a gay couple with a child and I’m just *smiles until cheeks hurt*

Avatar

this is so wholesome and sad...

Avatar

And that in some Hebrew-speaking cultures ‘ben’ means ‘child of’.

Avatar

I thought it was only MJ who was canonically Jewish... is it both? Either way this is fuckin lovely

Avatar

I don't think either is canonically Jewish; comicbookreligion.com lists Peter as Protestant and MJ as Christian (denomination unknown), but they don't list any sources so I can't verify (that site's generally reliable ime, tho). But Spider-Man came from a time when characters were Christian by default (Kitty Pryde as the first Jewish superhero was notable in 1980), and it's commonly believed that Peter is Jewish coded, much like Ben Grimm. But while Ben was confirmed Jewish in the early 2000s, while Peter has never been canonically confirmed. But stuff like this makes for a strong argument in support of the Jewish coding interpretation. What you're probably thinking of is in Into the Spiderverse, Peter B Parker had a flashback to his Jewish wedding, meaning either Peter and/or MJ is canonically Jewish in that universe.

Avatar

A less this post

Avatar

Damnit Spiderman ya made me cry

Avatar

Unless the answer is a girl. Then he suggests Gwen.

Avatar

@xphilosoraptorx It might not be canon in every interpretation. He’s Jewish in the TASM movies, and in Into The Spider-Verse.

Avatar

@xphilosoraptorx TASM didn't, really, but Andrew Garfield has said that he's Jewish. There a few blink and you'll miss it moments in ITSV, like Peter and MJ's wedding including Jewish traditions. There's also a holiday promo picture somewhere where Peter is holding a Hannukah mug. So nothing too big.

Avatar

oh my fsm this is beautiful